I get this question all the time, “If I am going to homeschool, does it really matter what grade my kids are in?”
No. And yes.
Here is what I think.
Homeschooling gives you a unique chance to meet your kids where they are. Teach them on the level that they are. If that means they are 6 years old and reading on a 5th grade level, go with it. If they are 6th grade and still struggling with addition, then drop back and learn addition. In the core subjects you will never catch up by skipping something that they don’t understand. So, no I don’t think grade level matters. It is ok for a 2nd grader to be doing 3 grade grammar, 2nd grade math and 5th grade reading.
So why so I care what grade they are in at all?
Here are our reasons, in no particular order
1. The law
The biggest reason for us it that we live in a state that requires us to report. On the form we fill out we have to say what grade the kids are in, and what grade they were in last year.
2. Graduation
We believe in 13 years of school. If our kids work ahead and finish trig, calculus, and statistics while they are in high school, that it great. But until they have finished 12th grade, they are still high school students. They may be dual enrolled high school students, but they are still under our care. In other words, we won’t graduate them early just because they are doing work that is the same as the average senior in high school.
So we figure out when we want our kids to graduate, subtract 13 years, and that is when we start kindergarten.
3. Other people-adults
Often times family, people at church, the pediatrician and random people at Wal-Mart will ask my kids what grade they are in. Most of the time they are just trying to make polite conversation with kids, and don’t know what to talk about. I have been around some homeschool kids that will answer this question “We homeschool.” or “We don’t do grades.” While some others just answer with their ages.
For some reason this has always struck me as impolite. (I am not sure that it actually is impolite, it just seems that way to me.) If nothing else it causes this awkward moment for both the kids, and the adults. And normally leaves the parents feeling like that have to explain or justify their homeschool choices.
4. Other people-children
For kids it is a way to compare how grown up another kid it. So teaching my kids their grade level allows them to integrate easier at church, VBS, camp, and any other time they are playing with kids.
5. For my own kids,
My kids like to know that they are accomplishing something in school. We school partially year around, so at the end of May we have a special day so celebrate the last day of what ever grade we are in. It doesn’t necessarily mean that we have finished all of our books. We are all over the place on grade levels and we finish text books all through the years and just pick up with the next book. History is the one exception for us. We do start a new section of history when we change grades.
6. Grades are used for placement
Grade levels are used for placement in many things, from camp, Sunday School and VBS to sports and education competitions. I also try to remember that on day my kids will be competing against the brightest kids in the country for positions in college. I caution people again skipping grades when they are homeschooling in elementary school. A kid that is doing really well on year, may start to struggle when they are older. And at that point if you hold them in the same grade for an extra year it will look, at least on paper, that they failed a grade.
What ever grade the child is in, is the grade that they have to compete in, across the board. That means they have to be in the same level in Math bowl, as they are in community soccer. It is definitely something to consider, before declaring a grade, or skipping a grade.
When it comes to homeschooling there are many things that I battle over. It seems like there is always someone who has a problem with our choice to homeschool. I will always fight for the right to make our own choices in how we educate our kids. But for me, giving our kids a “grade” makes my life a little easier. And avoids some battles that I would just rather not fight.